Just in
TechJD Earnings: Q3 Net Income Rises 23% on 3.5% Revenue GrowthTechBank Outage Today: Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo Users HitTechBlackstone Amazon Data Center Deal: BXDC Takes 75% of 13 Sites for $5BTechNationwide Emergency Alert Test Set for Nov. 17 at 2:20 p.m. ETTechXPeng Earnings: Q3 Revenue Rises 19% to $3.62 BillionCryptoBitmine Ethereum Holdings Hit 6.08 Million ETH, Total Falls to $11.8B
Crypto

CFTC Prediction Markets Lawsuits Target Arkansas and Louisiana

The CFTC filed suits against Arkansas and Louisiana on Nov. 13, saying federal law gives it sole authority over event contracts on registered exchanges.

USA Publishing Group3 min read
Share
Lady Justice statue holding scales atop a stone courthouse, tied to the CFTC lawsuits against two states
Photo: Chris Bischoff / Unsplash

Key takeaways

  • The CFTC said a Louisiana state court order on Nov. 12 shut down operations in the state for more than 30 companies tied to CFTC regulated derivatives.
  • Arkansas is pursuing a state court enforcement action against Kalshi that the CFTC said seeks penalties of up to hundreds of millions of dollars.
  • Louisiana is the 12th state the CFTC has sued to defend its jurisdiction, and both complaints seek injunctive and declaratory relief.
In this story 4 sections
  1. What Arkansas and Louisiana did
  2. What the CFTC wants from the courts
  3. A growing list of state fights
  4. What comes next

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission sued two states on the same day over event contracts. In releases dated Nov. 13, the federal regulator said it had filed suits against Arkansas and Louisiana, arguing that only the CFTC can police prediction markets listed on exchanges it oversees. With those two cases, the CFTC prediction markets lawsuit campaign now covers 12 states, by the agency's own count.

Louisiana is the more urgent of the pair. According to the CFTC's Louisiana release, a Louisiana state court on Thursday, Nov. 12, granted an order that shut down operations in the state for more than 30 companies tied to trading derivatives regulated by the CFTC. The agency said those firms got no notice and no chance to be heard before the order was issued.

What Arkansas and Louisiana did

  1. Arkansas brought a civil enforcement action in state court against Kalshi, an exchange the CFTC has designated as a contract market. The CFTC said the state wants event contract trading stopped and is pursuing penalties that could reach hundreds of millions of dollars against registered exchanges.
  2. Louisiana filed what the CFTC described as an emergency lawsuit and won the Nov. 12 order. The release does not name the companies affected.

What the CFTC wants from the courts

In both cases the agency filed a complaint for injunctive and declaratory relief. Against Louisiana, it asks a court to bar the state from prohibiting event contracts offered by designated contract markets, futures commission merchants and derivatives clearing organizations under CFTC supervision. The agency said the aim is to keep the status quo in place while federal courts decide the underlying question.

Against Arkansas, the CFTC's Arkansas release says the regulator wants the state's effort to halt trading, and the civil penalties attached to it, blocked.

The legal theory is the same in both suits. The CFTC points to the Commodity Exchange Act and says Congress handed it exclusive jurisdiction over derivatives markets, so state moves against registered exchanges are preempted by federal law. Neither release identifies the court where the complaints were filed. Both complaints are posted on the agency's website.

"Event contracts have traded openly in Louisiana for years, in compliance with the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC regulations," CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig said in the Louisiana release. He also described the state's suit as "naked lawfare and a cynical political stunt."

A growing list of state fights

Arkansas became the 11th state the CFTC has sued to defend its authority over these markets, and Louisiana became the 12th, according to the two releases. Neither one names the earlier states. The agency added that it has also filed friend of the court briefs in four federal appeals courts and one state supreme court.

The cases land during a busy stretch for the commission. Earlier this month, a group that includes Cboe and Citadel sued the CFTC over stock perpetual futures, and the Senate is weighing two nominees who would join the agency's only sitting commissioner.

What comes next

The releases give no hearing dates and no timeline for a ruling in either state. What the courts decide will shape whether a state can stop a federally registered exchange from offering event contracts to people inside its borders, a question that now spans a dozen states. More rulings and regulator actions are tracked in our crypto and markets regulation coverage.